Joe Guyon and Jim Thorpe Canton Bulldogs

Canton Bulldogs (1920-1923) (1925-1926)

Canton Bulldogs

National Football League (1920-1923)(1925-1926)

Tombstone

Born: September 17, 1920 – American Professional Football Association (NFL from 1922) founding franchise1Football Men Organize, The Youngstown Vindicator, Sep. 18, 1920
Sold/relocated: August 5, 1924 (Cleveland Bulldogs)2Cleveland In Football Body,  Rochester Journal and Post, Aug. 6, 1924
Re-established: July 18, 19253Canton Bulldogs to Return in Fall, The Gazette Times, Jul. 19, 1925
Folded: April 21, 19274“Fat” Henry Will Not Back Professional Team, The Washington Reporter, Apr. 21, 1927

First Game (after joining APFA): October 3, 1920 (W vs. Pitcairn Quakers  48-0)
First Game (vs. league opponent): October 17, 1920 (W vs. Cleveland Tigers 7-0)
Last Game: November 28, 1926 (L @ Chicago Bears 35-0)

NFL Championships: 1922, 1923

Stadium

Lakeside Park (1920-1927)
Opened: October 3, 1920 (As Athletic Field at Meyer’s Park)5Football Inaugural Here Certain For Sunday, The Canton Daily News, Sat. Oct. 2, 1920
Closed: 1950(?)

Canton Bulldogs (1920-1923) (1925-1926) logo, uniforms, and team history photo
The Canton Bulldogs prepare to open the city’s new stadium with their first game of the 1920 season.

Marketing

Team Colors: Maroon and white6TruColor.net

Ownership

Owners:

Ralph Hay (1920-1924)

Ben Jones, Link Lyman, Harry Robb, Rudolph Comstock, Wilbur “Fat” Henry (1925-1926)

 

Background

The Canton Bulldogs were a founding member of the National Football League (NFL), which was established in 1920 as the American Professional Football Association. The Bulldogs were in the league from 1920 to 1923 and again from 1925 through 1926.

​The team was formed as an amateur concern in 1904 under the auspices of the Canton Athletic Club. In 1905 the Bulldogs joined the Ohio League. They won the 1906 league title in, according to one newspaper account, “one of the greatest football battles ever witnessed in (Canton).” The Bulldogs beat the Massillon Tigers 10-5 in that game.7Canton Won Great Game From Massillon Tigers, The Washington (Pa.) Reporter, Nov. 17, 1906.

Canton left the Ohio League before the start of the 1907 season but rejoined for the 1911campaign.  In 1915, legendary Olympic athlete Jim Thorpe joined the Bulldogs and later became head coach. The Bulldogs stayed in the Ohio League until that loop ceased operations at the end of the 1919 season. 

The NFL is formed

​After that final season, many Ohio League team owners sought to form a more structured circuit that would also include teams from outside of the Buckeye State. This resulted in the formation of the American Professional Football Association (APFA) on September 17, 1920, in the showroom of  Ralph Hay’s Jordan & Humpmobile car dealership. Hay also owned the Bulldogs. Jim Thorpe was named league president.

​Two weeks later, on October 3, 1920, the first games between league opponents were held as the Dayton Triangles hosted the Columbus Panhandles, and the Rock Island Independents welcomed the Muncie Flyers. The rest of the APFA teams played non-league opponents, including the Bulldogs, who hosted the Pitcairn Quakers from suburban Pittsburgh at the brand new Athletic Field at Meyer’s Lake, a local amusement park. For most of its existence it was used for minor league baseball, but it was the Bulldogs who christened the field that day. Canton won handily, 48-0.

Canton Bulldogs (1920-1923) (1925-1926) logo, uniforms, and team history photo

 

Two weeks after that game, the Bulldogs, led by Thorpe, faced fellow APFA member the Cleveland Tigers, beating them 7-0 before 7,000 Canton football fans.8Thorpians Outclass Tigers Of Cleveland, The Canton Daily News, Oct. 18, 1920 Ike Martin, the Bulldogs halfback, scored the winning touchdown 12 minutes into the game. A local newspaper reported that the final score was not indicative of Canton’s domination of the Cleveland eleven.

Slow burn

​In 1920, the Bulldogs posted a record of 7-4-2, good for 8th place in the 14-team field. The Pros from neighboring Akron won the title that year. A total of 21 teams made up the APFA in 1921, though not all of them completed the season. Joe Carr became league president and replaced Jim Thorpe. The famous athelete took a year off to play baseball with the minor league Toledo Mudhens. He turned up in 1922 as a player/coach for the Oorang Indians, a team of mostly Native American players based in Marion, OH. The Bulldogs, meanwhile, went 5-4-3 to finish in 4th place in their second APFA season.

​Things came together in 1922 as the APFA became the National Football League. The Bulldogs finished that season 10-0-2, and captured the first (technically) NFL title. They repeated that feat in 1923, as they improved to 11-0-1. They captured the title by beating the (football) Indians 46-10 in a week 9 game played in Cleveland. 

Move to Cleveland

​Less than a month after the end of the season, local newspapers were reporting that the team was going to be purchased by Sam Deutsch, owner of the league’s Cleveland team.9Doc Elliott May Go To Cleveland In Gigantic Football Deal, The Canton Daily News, Jan. 28, 1924 That deal was consummated on August 2. An eleventh-hour deal to keep the team in Canton failed.10Canton Citizens Want to Keep Team Here, The Canton Daily News, Aug. 5, 1924 Deutsch merged the rosters of his Cleveland Indians with that of his newly acquired Canton eleven to form the Cleveland Bulldogs.11Cleveland In Football Body, The Rochester Journal and Post, Aug. 6, 1924

​Perhaps feeling badly for the Canton fans, Deutsch met with former John Carroll University coach Kay Martin to discuss a deal.12Former John Carroll Coach Plans Football Team Here, The Canton Daily News, Aug. 17, 1924 Deutsch would sell the Canton franchise to Martin (Cleveland already held a franchise), though Cleveland would keep the best players from the original Bulldogs roster. Martin would form a new Canton team with the players not taken by Deutsch. The deal never came to fruition, though, and Canton was not represented in the NFL in 1924.

New Canton Bulldogs

​Canton was back in the league, though, in 1925, when Wilbur “Fat” Henry, a star from the previous incarnation of the Bulldogs, agreed to lead a new team using the old name.13“Fat” Henry Is New President Of Canton Club, The Washington Daily Reporter, Aug. 17, 1925 Even though Deutsch’s club in Cleveland was still using the Bulldogs name, so to was the new Canton franchise.

​Only six members of the Bulldog’s 1923 championship team were on the roster of the 1925 edition of the club. The new team finished 4-4, just ahead of the Cleveland Bulldogs by percentage points as the two clubs played a different number of games.

​The team fell to 1-9-3 in 1926, 20th out of the 22-team league. The final home game was played on Thanksgiving Day, November 25, 1926, and resulted in a 0-0 tie with the Akron Pros.14For Second Straight Time, Bulldogs and Akron Play Tie, The Canton Daily News, Nov. 26, 1926. Three days later, the Bulldogs lost to the Chicago Bears 35-0 at Cubs Park (now Wrigley Field) in their final NFL conest.

Their poor on-field performance couldn’t have come at a worse time. The NFL was becoming more popular, particularly in the big markets. As such, the league was anxious to shed small towns and underperforming clubs.15Here’s Your Hat…1927 by Don Smith, The Pro Football Researchers Association, Dec. 18, 2010 At a February 1927 league meeting, the NFL decided to split into two 11-team divisions,16Sports, The Florence News Times-Daily, Feb. 7, 1926 but by the time they reconvened in August, they had instead decided to discharge 10 teams outright.17Pro Gridders’ League Prepares For ’27 Season, The Painesville Telegraph, Aug. 11, 1927 Canton was out long before that, though. In April, “Fat” Henry had announced he would not run the franchise for 1927.18“Fat” Henry Will Not Back Professional Team,  The Washington Daily Reporter, Apr. 21, 1927 An attempt to get other local backers failed, and the team went out of business.

Legacy

​On May 6, 1964, the Cleveland Bulldogs of the minor United Football League moved to Canton,19Canton Once Again Had Pro Grid Club, AP via The Massillon Evening Independent, May 7, 1964 thus reviving the Canton Bulldogs name. Those Bulldogs finished with a record of 12-2 and captured what would be the final UFL title. In 2024, the “new” United States Football League trademarked the Canton Bulldogs name. The league, coincidentally, now operates as the United Football League (after a merger with the “new” XFL) but has announced no plans to place a team in Canton as of this posting.

 

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Share